It was with equal parts astonishment and disappointment that I received an advance copy of Mr. Dershowitzs response to my article from about a month ago. Obviously, I disagree with the context of his accusations, but the tone and reasoning of his argument is very troubling. Reading his comments was the sad end of a personal journey of admiration that I had for the Professor. Starting in high school, I believed Dershowitz to be a great man of principle and reason, but this impression has continued to erode over the last five years to the point where I now recognize Dershowitz in the same light as many of his high-profile critics–a man who has betrayed his liberal and, more importantly, academic principles for a life of demagoguery and needless antagonism. With Dershowitzs letter to The Hoot this week, two things are now obvious: First, Carter was undeniably astute in his refusal to debate a professor who has forgotten the basic standards of constructive academic debate, and second, Dershowitz himself was left defeated by the Carter event as he witnessed a community that, for the most part, cared little for what he had to say.